The past is too tight
How to make a film to accompany a live orchestral performance of a symphony? There are already 80 musicians in the orchestra. There is the shine of the brass. The excitement of watching the relationship between the conductor and the musicians. Behind this, to put a film.
The key task in making the film Oh To Believe in Another World to accompany the Shostakovich symphony no. 10, is to find something that does not turn the symphony into film music – a series of images and narratives that overwhelm the music itself; nor to have something that disappears, that runs simply as series of anodyne backdrops. But the story of Shostakovich and his complicated relationship to the state in the Soviet Union, from its early days just after the 1917 revolution, all the way through to Stalin’s death in 1953, provides the material for thinking visually about the trajectory that Shostakovich had to follow, from the early days of the Soviet Union to the writing of the symphony.
-
+ Credits
Oh To Believe in Another World
A film to accompany the performance of Shostakovich Symphony No. 10 in E Minor
Director
William Kentridge
Editors
Janus Fouché, Žana Marović
Costume & Puppet Designer
Greta Goiris
Set & Model Designer
Sabine Theunissen
Cinematographer
Duško Marović SASC
Video Control
Kim Gunning
Assistant Director of Chorus
Nhlanhla Mahlangu
Performers
Thulani Chauke, Luc De Wit, Andrea Fabi, Teresa Phuti Mojela and Phuphuma Love Minus (Isicathamiya chorus)
Costume and Puppet Makers
Emmanuelle Erhart, Judith Stokart assisted by Diego Sillands
Model Makers
Damon Garstang, Claire Zinn
Associate Editor
Joshua Trappler
Assistant Compositor
Octavia Sonyane
Camera Operators and Technical Direction
Chris-Waldo de Wet, Jacques van Staden
Production Management
Taryn Buccellato
Studio Director
Anne McIlleron
Administration
Linda Leibowitz, Natalie Dembo
Project Initiator
Numa Bischof Ullmann
Executive Producer
THE OFFICE performing arts + film
Comissioned by the Luzerner Sinfonieorchester and made possible through a grant by the Art Mentor Foundation Lucerne.
World premiere: KKL, Lucerne, 15 June, 2022
Oh To Believe in Another World
Five channel film installation
15 min 42 sec
Director
William Kentridge
Editor & Sound Designer
Janus Fouché
Additional Editors
Žana Marović, Joshua Trappler
Costume & Puppet Designer
Greta Goiris
Set & Model Designer
Sabine Theunissen
Cinematographer
Duško Marović SASC
Performers
Thulani Chauke, Luc De Wit, Andrea Fabi, Teresa Phuti Mojela and Phuphuma Love Minus (Isicathamiya chorus)
Assistant Director of Chorus
Nhlanhla Mahlangu
Costume and Puppet Makers
Emmanuelle Erhart, Judith Stokart assisted by Diego Sillands
Model Makers
Damon Garstang, Claire Zinn
Compositor
Janus Fouché
Assistant Compositor
Octavia Sonyane
Camera Operators and Technical Direction
Chris-Waldo de Wet, Jacques van Staden
Production Management
Taryn Buccellato
Studio Director
Anne McIlleron
Administration
Linda Leibowitz, Natalie Dembo
Making
The film is set inside what appears to be an abandoned Soviet museum, which in fact is made of cardboard, on the table in the artist’s studio (at times there are fragments of the studio visible). Using a miniature camera, we move through the different halls of the museum, which also include a community theatre hall, a public swimming pool, a quarry at the side of the main halls of the museum. A corridor of vitrines holding stuffed historical figures.
This is a retrospective look at the four decades of the 1920s, 30s, 40s, and 50s, from the perspective of 1953 when both Stalin died and the first performance of the symphony was presented. In the 1920s there was the death of Lenin; in the 1930s the suicide of Mayakovsky; in the 1940s, the assassination of Trotsky; in the 1950s the death of Stalin – and here we are, almost 70 years later. The report that remains of these decades is in the music of Shostakovich, the one who against expectation got away, and survived.
The central characters of the film are Lenin, Trotsky and Stalin; Shostakovich and his student Elmira Nazirova (about which there are different theories regarding her relationship with Shostakovich and the 10th Symphony and whether her name is embedded into some of the key signatures of the symphony); Mayakovsky and his lover Lily Brik. These characters appear as puppets, but are also performed by actors inside of puppets. The form is one of collage, and the larger proposition is that one needs to understand history as a form of collage. The artistic medium is a way of thinking about the historical events.
The task of the project is to try to show within the visual film some of the ambiguities Shostakovich had to negotiate, not just in this symphony, but in all the work that he made. We have to find a way to both acknowledge the independence of the music – that it exists now in the post-Soviet era (we can still feel the emotional journey of the symphony, independent of its historical moorings); but at the same time acknowledge the particular character of the era from which it comes.
Performance
Single channel projection to accompany live performance of Shostakovich Symphony No. 10 in E Minor
Film Installation
Five channel HD video
Drawings
Sculpture
Prints
Exhibitions
More projects
Credits
Oh To Believe in Another World
A film to accompany the performance of Shostakovich Symphony No. 10 in E Minor
Director
William Kentridge
Editors
Janus Fouché, Žana Marović
Costume & Puppet Designer
Greta Goiris
Set & Model Designer
Sabine Theunissen
Cinematographer
Duško Marović SASC
Video Control
Kim Gunning
Assistant Director of Chorus
Nhlanhla Mahlangu
Performers
Thulani Chauke, Luc De Wit, Andrea Fabi, Teresa Phuti Mojela and Phuphuma Love Minus (Isicathamiya chorus)
Costume and Puppet Makers
Emmanuelle Erhart, Judith Stokart assisted by Diego Sillands
Model Makers
Damon Garstang, Claire Zinn
Associate Editor
Joshua Trappler
Assistant Compositor
Octavia Sonyane
Camera Operators and Technical Direction
Chris-Waldo de Wet, Jacques van Staden
Production Management
Taryn Buccellato
Studio Director
Anne McIlleron
Administration
Linda Leibowitz, Natalie Dembo
Project Initiator
Numa Bischof Ullmann
Executive Producer
THE OFFICE performing arts + film
Comissioned by the Luzerner Sinfonieorchester and made possible through a grant by the Art Mentor Foundation Lucerne.
World premiere: KKL, Lucerne, 15 June, 2022
Oh To Believe in Another World
Five channel film installation
15 min 42 sec
Director
William Kentridge
Editor & Sound Designer
Janus Fouché
Additional Editors
Žana Marović, Joshua Trappler
Costume & Puppet Designer
Greta Goiris
Set & Model Designer
Sabine Theunissen
Cinematographer
Duško Marović SASC
Performers
Thulani Chauke, Luc De Wit, Andrea Fabi, Teresa Phuti Mojela and Phuphuma Love Minus (Isicathamiya chorus)
Assistant Director of Chorus
Nhlanhla Mahlangu
Costume and Puppet Makers
Emmanuelle Erhart, Judith Stokart assisted by Diego Sillands
Model Makers
Damon Garstang, Claire Zinn
Compositor
Janus Fouché
Assistant Compositor
Octavia Sonyane
Camera Operators and Technical Direction
Chris-Waldo de Wet, Jacques van Staden
Production Management
Taryn Buccellato
Studio Director
Anne McIlleron
Administration
Linda Leibowitz, Natalie Dembo